Poverty, Power and a Bakery

P1010419

A few years ago now I was working with an NGO in a remote region of Central Asia. I was helping to set up a pilot project that would provide vocational training and help to start small businesses.

Most of my work involved teaching and facilitating apprenticeships in areas such as mechanics and welding. One part of my work was slightly different however: setting up a small bakery.

A man – lets call him Abdullah – came to be a part of the initial interview for students in the vocational training programme. He was heavily in debt and had a family to support. A past injury left him with a permanent limp and difficulty walking for any length of time.

I asked him about his previous experience and he explained his background in a confectionery as well as baking and selling a type of stuffed flat bread. Given his age and interests, he didn’t really fit the profile of students that we were looking for. After consulting with my local colleagues however we decided to offer him an opportunity to help us set up and run a trial bakery business.

We didn’t have the mandate or capacity to give him a monetary loan, and given his level of debt this would not have been wise anyway. Instead, we used project funds to purchase the needed equipment and then let him use our equipment on a trial basis. If the business was a success we would provide him the opportunity to purchase the equipment from us. If it failed there was no loss to him and we would be free to sell the equipment elsewhere.

As it turned out the business was very successful. Previously, baked goods were imported from larger cities and often took days to arrive in the local market. Once Abdullah’s bakery was up and running shops began to buy fresh products from him. In holiday times he could not keep up with the demand.

P1010430

Soon Abdullah expanded the business and took on three apprentices. He began to buy the equipment from our project and by the time I left the country, he was on track to purchase all of it by the end of the year.

About a year later I heard from local colleagues that his business was still running successfully. He had begun to export baked goods to other towns and villages. This enabled him to start paying back his large financial loans as well.

P1010421

Sadly however, his success did not last long.  He went into partnership with a relative in order to expand the business further. This relative began to take over and mismanage many aspects of the business and help himself to money. Conflicts arose and Abdullah decided that his only way out was to cut his losses, sell his share in the business and find work in a neighboring country.

I’ve often felt saddened and discouraged by his story. It seems that good opportunities, training and hard work are not always enough for people to escape poverty. Unequal power structures and other people’s greed seems to lock them into a cycle that is hard to break free from.

 

 

 

10 thoughts on “Poverty, Power and a Bakery

  1. I completely understand how you feel. As a charity worker, that has been the case for my husband and I over the years. Sometimes we even ask ourselves, “What is the point.” But then we persevere and simply help one person at a time, do what we can and then leave it. A good outcome was Abdullah got out of debt. Helping those caught in poverty rarely has the outcome we desire; however, it is still worth helping (one person at a time). You may never know the future good. Thank you for posting this story!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I thought that this was a great story. Perhaps it’s just the way life is, some people also need to take some knocks for the lessons they still need to learn. I doubt that your efforts were wasted. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thank you for sharing. It just means we have to figure out how to address that perhaps an insurance scheme. You tried to help and not trying is worse no matter how it turned out.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s